This one was a tough call. Ask any Puerto Rican and they immediately jump to say mofongo is from la isla del encanto. And then Dominicans claim it, too. Since both sides feel strongly about the dish, we decided it was time to see whose mofongo truly stands out. We invited a Dominican, a Puerto Rican, and a neutral guest to have a bite and tell us: Whose mofongo is the best? They tasted mofongo from some of New York’s top-rated restaurants on Yelp, the Puerto Rican Casa Adela and Dominican El Malecón.