Demi Lovato launched her own capsule collection with NYC New York Color called the Lovatics Collection in January, and we’ve been eagerly waiting to get our hands on it ever since. The line, which consists of a 12-shade eyeshadow palette, four lip and cheek tints, mascara, and two brow pencils, is affordable, with each item coming in at less than $5.

We just had to test the products out for ourselves, so we had our lovely model and Vivala insider Rosemary Roman sit in our makeup chair as we tried to re-create Lovato’s signature smoky eye and bold cheek.

While the mascara was dry and crumbly, the eyeshadow palette is the star of the line (though we amped up the color by using a black pencil as a base). The brow pencils are also on point. Tread carefully with the lip and cheek tints, though — a little goes a really long way.